Dark Auction Review (PS5) | Push Square

In Dark Auction, it’s been three days since Noah last saw his dad

His father is obsessed with collecting objects related to a World War 2 tyrant named Dictator X, and after setting off to take part in a mysterious auction he hasn’t been seen since.

So, Noah decides to head to the castle where he was last seen only to get pulled into something way more dangerous than he expected.

The story premise is slightly bonkers but surprisingly compelling. This isn’t an ordinary auction; rather than money, bidders have to offer up one of their own memories. The other five participants are also seeking items related to Dictator X, and they all have their own messy family history tied to WW2. Some of these stories are quite morally grey if not outright black.

The device used to extract memories can cause intense pain and even kill someone if it detects any lies. Trauma or buried secrets can corrupt a memory and so it’s your job to spot any inconsistencies and “fix” the memory so that the bidder survives. It’s only by doing this that you’ll be able to learn the truth behind the auction and what has happened to Noah’s father.

Outside the auctions, most of your time is spent exploring the castle and talking to the other participants to gather clues. The story is very linear, but the character writing is strong enough that it doesn’t feel restrictive. Watching Noah slowly earn everyone’s trust and uncover how their families’ pasts connect to Dictator X is genuinely compelling.

The auctions themselves are the weak point. They’re a bit like the trials in Danganronpa but far simpler. Each night you’re doing the same handful of tasks; fill in the blanks, point out contradictions, repeat. It’s not bad, just repetitive.

One thing that does stand out in a bad way is the use of generative AI art. A lot of the memory scenes and auction items leverage the technology, and it clashes hard with the gorgeous illustrations by KOHSKE.

To its credit, the developer has said it’s working on replacing some of the generative AI assets, but we can only comment on what we played.

All that said, even with its slow moments and uneven presentation, Dark Auction’s writing and mystery kept us hooked. If you enjoy character‑driven visual novels with a darker edge, then it’s worth a look.