Obi-Wan Kenobi Suddenly released this spring in a storm of excitement, including breathtaking articles Declare the merits of the first part..Fans not only wanted to see Obi-Wan and Anakin Skywalker / Anakin Skywalker again, but the protagonist Star Wars Episode I-III — But they were also excited to see the former actors Ewan McGregor and Hayden Christensen playing. So many people were excited when the show debuted. Then slowly the realizations of almost every Star Wars project began … isn’t that great?
This is all the reason Star Wars shows and movies Recut, rewritten, restaging, reconceptualized, and backflowed by online fans to create better quality Star Wars. The latest fan remix to get widespread attention — Article variety — — Kai Patterson compressed the six episodes of the show into a two-and-a-half-hour feature film, which Patterson created to modify what was “easy to fix in a script or edit.”
Does this new version actually “fix” the show issue? Is that okay? Is it yet another example of how a more common sense storytelling and filmmaking can be applied to radically improve a flawed original? Obi-Wan Kenobi The series certainly had problems, but if Disney chooses to go the movie route like Patterson’s edits, does that make it a better Star Wars experience?
Series problems
The show starts slowly.Do you really need to see Obi-Wan in a blue-collar job Three separate times to hide and get a sense of his life 10 years after the events of the first part? However, viewers are to introduce Ewan McGregor (an even better character in the series) and his precocious future Hat Strangler, 10-year-old Leia Organa (Vivian). In addition, he had patience in the setup (Lira Brea). The first episode has other good points, such as an exciting opening sequence in which Young Ring escapes from the emperor’s Jedi purge. Revenge of the Sith..
The second episode of Obi-Wan looking for kidnapped Leia feels a bit rushed, but the action and VFX are fascinating. Inquisitor Leva (Moses Ingram) is a demonic villain enough. More importantly, after spending too much time on its intolerable sandball, Tatooine Boba Fett’s book When Mandalorian, Star Wars At the end Depart for another hive of scum and villainy: Cool Blade Runner-Like planetDaiyu.
Episode 3 gave viewers a true belief that Disney understood the series correctly. The episode features a chilling look by Darth Vader. His classic Rogue One exterior.. The savagery of Vader’s battle with Obi-Wan, the intensity of his hatred, and the complete lack of preparation for Obi-Wan’s encounter are touching and disturbing.
After that, the show delivered the first weak episode. Episode 4 is not only Leia’s rescue mission, but yet another episode, after two episodes of the first episode. “respect” Rescue of Leia from the Death Star in a previous Star Wars story New hope, Already “rethought” as a rescue of Ray (Daisy Ridley) from Starkiller Base Force Awakening..
It was in this episode that some viewers wondered if the show had a problem. Among other problems, Obi-Wan is almost fine after suffering severe physical and mental injuries in Vader’s hands at the end of episode 3. Then he and the Jedi sympathizer Tara (Indira Varma) easily infiltrated the perhaps impregnable Imperial base, and Obi-Wan sneaked into the water using a breathing device.
Unfortunately, the episode misses the beat when Obi-Wan later tries to stop the hordes of stormtroopers and threatens to flood the corridor where he is. “You have a breathtaking device with you. Put it in, drown these mothers and swim from there!”
Unfortunately, such an elegant reward does not appear from previous setups that more or less summarize the entire series. Next, you’ll get the now infamous scene where Obi-Wan and Tara jump out of the fortress and Leia is hidden under a trench coat. Even assuming you have a trench coat at hand (maybe for cosplay?), Imperial officers seem to have a fairly stiff facial hair cord, and Obi-Wan seems to have a rough sleep after a rough sleep. Looks like a lip van winkle.
Episode 5 is an improvement and probably the best episode in the series.It doesn’t just provide more Vader badasseryHowever, as much of Leva’s backstory and motivation becomes apparent, we recognize her as a more empathetic and persuasive person. Finally, in an elegant staging training duel flashback with Obi-Wan, Hayden Christensen can be seen as a young Anakin.
The last episode undoes much of what the penultimate episode restores. This shows how the settled Star Wars canon constrains the drama, not just because of the clinge dialog and lazy plots.Episode provides parallel subplot Vader and Obi-Wan Clashing with Tatooine, Leva threatened a young Luke Skywalker at home. But both plots, even if the battle between Vader and Obi-Wan brought some emotional closure to their relationship, as it turns out that neither Luke nor Obi-Wan are actually at risk. I feel rushed and anti-climatic.
Something that even the details are wrong and Star Wars can usually rely on.How they completely wiped out all those First Order cruisers after we knew that Star Destroyer could do with a tractor beam and a squad of TIE. The Last JediFor example, suddenly, Skywalker’s Star Destroyer can barely hit or catch the junk in front of it (when the hero seems to be a few seconds after his death, he has a lot of heartfelt conversations on board. Don’t worry about that). Finally, filmmaking is substandard in this episode.but New TV Dolby Dark SettingsIn the night scene, not illuminated by the lightsaber, I could hardly see the action (did not do it game of thrones Do you want to tell them anything?). It feels like a filmmaker trying to improve his skills, but in the end he can’t break in.
I have no idea where to go
Overall problem Obi-Wan Kenobi It was that there was no place to go.Everything is in almost the same place as when we started, except that Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) finally appeared after 10 years of production. photograph Anyone who knows what to do in the desert until movies and Obi-Wan Kenault events New hope. Still, we always knew that the show would be a narrative dead end, as there is no real danger to legacy characters. Was it more suspenseful and emotionally involved? Showrunner tried Leva’s arc because it didn’t have an unprecedented conclusion, but in the final episode he broke it with the treatment of her character’s ham fist.
So what’s left? Some cool new environments, some great lightsaber battles (with almost every repeat of Star Wars), great moments with Obi-Wan, Leia, Organus, immortal Vader’s wickedness-some average More episodes and some mediocre ones.
What will change the movie version?
The goal of his version of Patterson was to improve the pace and get rid of fluff. He usually achieves this by cutting out the most material from the three weakest episodes, 1, 4, and 6. He completely removes the weakest part of the series, the subplot where Reva goes to Skywalker’s mansion. This will make the final battle between Obi-Wan and Anakin more impactful. Star Wars is famous for its effective use of parallel actions, but Patterson shows that a better choice here is to build a duel without interrupting the emotional climax.
In contrast, the first act of his cut (about 25 minutes) feels truncated and choppy without sufficient setup and explanation. For example, Patterson omits the scene where Leia insults her cousin at Aldebaran’s diplomatic reception. This isn’t a big deal except when leaving the late scene (Jimmy Smits) between Leia and his father. She apologized for the incident, but it’s no longer in the movie. These early scenes in the series also more establish Leia’s personality, her bullishness, and her desire for autonomy. We rarely spend time with her in Patterson’s version before she is kidnapped, so our compassion and our understanding of how competent she is is so developed. not.
Causes and effects are sometimes confusing.In the series, I think the Inquisitor has appeared on Tatooine and is looking for Obi-Wan until it is discovered. Another Jedi and Obi-Wan ally, Nari (Benny Safdie) barely runs away. After a few scenes, Nari finds Obi-Wan and asks for his help in dealing with this new danger.In Patterson’s version, Nari finds Obi-Wan wandering the desert at night. Previous Inquisitor arrives.Not only is it a very annoying transition, but the viewer has never seen who Nari is or he is almost killed, so his to find Obi-Wan I don’t know what the motive is..
One of the things that Star Wars fans were pleased with was that Patterson included more of John Williams’ music. This includes the famous fateful battle scores. Phantom Menace.. The music in Natalie Ann Holt’s series is completely inspiring, but Patterson instinctively understands that our pulse races a bit faster when we hear the Master’s theme.
Does the movie make the show material better?
Most, but not perfect. The film ironically emphasizes how well many scenes of the show are done in terms of filmmaking, which is a testament to the overall quality of the series (except for McGregor and Christensen). It remains mediocre). The story’s momentum is already working pretty well in episodes 2, 3, and 5 of the show, so it makes sense that Patterson’s cuts flow better in these sections of the movie as well. Not surprisingly, editing the material in his fewer episodes, especially his transition from episodes 5 to 6, isn’t that smooth.
Not omitting the entire episode 4 is probably Patterson’s biggest mistake (he can still fix it in future edits if he so desires). Yes, the episode has some decent actions, Great visual effects, And a fashionable production design. But even more than television, movies can’t repeat beats. They always need to escalate their stakes in new ways. That is, you cannot include two rescues that narratively achieve the same thing. Patterson easily cuts into Obi-Wan, who recovers in the Bactatank after the battle with Vader, just before Leva kidnaps Leia at the end of Season 3, and joins the refugees at the beginning of the episode Obi-Wan, Leia, Tara. I was able to cut into 5, with the empire on the way.
About the question Obi-Wan Kenobi It should be a movie, not a series, but a better question would be: Why tell this particular story when we all know what it will be? The fascinating drama runs with just the right recipe for surprise and suspense, and both are compromised when we know the end. traitor When Clone Wars I had a better idea How to use legacy characters. This wasn’t always involved as a lead and often deviated from the Star Wars main story.
Would you like to give Obi-Wan a secret love and then send him on a mission to help her on a planet we haven’t seen yet? If Obi-Wan confronts the loss of someone he loves deeply, you are betting on real danger, especially given the guilt he already feels against Anakin. In other words, if you need new Star Wars stories, stop filling the gaps and start expanding them. That said, Patterson once again proves that there is probably less when it comes to recontexting older material.
Would you like to trust us?You can see the cut of Kai Patterson Obi-Wan Kenobi here Determine for yourself if the series works well as a movie.
Editor’s recommendations
